How Tight Should Gloves Be? 5 Best Ways To Find Out

Last Updated on 06/03/2023

How Tight Should Gloves Be

How tight should gloves be? In this guide, we share the different types of gloves and how tightly they should fit. You will learn how to test if your gloves are too tight and whether it is better to order a size up or a size down.

We’ve all heard the saying, ‘fits like a glove’. Well, the reason that saying exists is that gloves are designed to slip right on and have a close fit.

If your gloves are too tight, they will feel uncomfortable. If your gloves are too loose, they will not keep your hands very warm, and you lose all dexterity in your fingers. Certain types of gloves like gloves for campfires are ok to be loose in exchange for being fireproof. Others like gloves used for bushcraft don’t necessarily have to warm but instead focus on being as durable and flexible as possible.

Your glove should be neither baggy nor tight. It should be just right!

How Tight Should Gloves Be?

Gloves should feel snug without restricting movement or feeling too narrow or short on the fingers. They should fit your hands the same way your shoes fit your feet. You want your fingertips to be almost or just touching the tips of the gloves.

If the tips of your fingers are pushing against the tips of your gloves, your gloves aren’t long enough and will feel too tight. Also, if the material feels like it is constricting your fingers, you need to try a size up.

Your gloves should never feel tight when you put them on. But, if you clench your fist, it is normal for your gloves to tighten. Your hands should slide into your gloves easily, but the gloves should not fall off your hands once on.

making a fist to check glove tightness

5 Ways to Know if Gloves Are Too Tight?

Here are five simple ways to test how tight gloves should be:

Do You Have to Force Them On

When you try on some gloves for the first time, you may know they are too tight before you get your hand all the way in. If you have to force the glove over your knuckles before you get your fingers in, this is not a good sign.

You should be able to pull a pair of gloves on fairly easily, and they should be tight enough so that they don’t fall off your hands as you are walking. If you find yourself having to squeeze your hands into a glove that feels too tight, then get a bigger pair.

Do Your Finger Tips Press Against the Ends

If your fingers are really pressed up against the tips of the gloves, this can become painful if your hands get cold or you are wearing them all day long.

When you put a pair of gloves on, you should generally pull them on as far as they will go, which should press up against your fingertips. But then, once they settle into position, your fingers should not be pressing against the fingertips of the gloves. You should have, as they say, some wiggle room.

Can You Make a Fist

An easy test you can do to tell if your gloves are too tight is to make a fist. If you can clench your fist all the way shut, then your gloves aren’t too tight. If your fingers press against the tips of the gloves with a fully clenched fist, that is fine.

If you can easily make a fist with your gloves on and there is any excess fabric beyond your fingertips, then your gloves may be too big.

Is the Thumb in The Right Place

With tight gloves, the fabric at the joint of the thumb will feel very uncomfortable on the stretch of skin between your thumb and forefinger (medically known as the thenar web space). When you pull your gloves on, if it feels like the fabric is preventing you from wearing the glove properly, then they are probably designed for smaller hands.

Do They Feel Tight

It may seem obvious, but evaluating how gloves feel is the best way to establish a good fit. When you try on a new pair of gloves, you should stretch all your fingers out and give them a wiggle, make a fist, and try to notice any spots that feel tight (or loose). If your instinct is telling you to try a slightly larger size, then listen to it. If it’s not a hell yes, it’s a no.

different types of gloves

Different Types of Gloves

It is important to recognize that there are lots of different types of gloves out there designed for very different purposes. Some gloves are designed to be baggy (oven gloves), some have no finger slots (boxing gloves and mittens), and others are meant to block heat, protect your knuckle, or provide dexterity in winter.

For the most part, this guide on how tight should gloves be can be applied to most styles of gloves. But here are some of the considerations for the activities I enjoy:

How Tight Should Cycling Gloves Be?

Because you will be keeping your hand in a mostly clenched position, you need to make sure you can make a fist without your gloves constricting your fingers. When you squeeze the brakes or change gear, you may need to use your thumb and fingers, so test these movements before heading out on your bike in your new gloves.

I would guess at least half of all cycling gloves are fingerless. Fingerless gloves mean that you don’t have to worry about your fingertips being too tight. It is quite normal for cycling gloves to feel quite tight. Because they need to be aerodynamic, they will have a slim fit and will often have small tags to help you pull them off your hands when you’re done.

How Tight Should Hiking Gloves Be?

How tight should gloves be for hiking? Hiking gloves don’t need to be tight or loose unless you plan on doubling them up.

I think it is quite important for you to have good dexterity with your fingers with hiking gloves. This is so you can still access your zips, operate your gadgets, and use your hands when necessary. If your hiking gloves are too baggy, then you struggle with them constantly, wanting to fall off your hands.

ski and snowboard gloves waving

How Tight Should Skiing Gloves Be?

Skiing gloves have a lot of insulation which makes them kind of clumsy to begin with. But they still need to be able to grip the handles of ski poles and open zips to access your ski pass, so they can’t be too tight or baggy. I like ski gloves that feel snug and packed with synthetic insulation, with my fingertips pretty close to the ends.

Ski gloves will often have a toggle or adjustable strap around the wrist, which helps to secure big gloves on your hand but can also add a little tightness. Many people also choose to wear a thin and stretchy pair of glove liners inside an insulated and waterproof outer glove. If this is you, then it makes sense to get a pair that are slightly larger.

How Tight Should Snowboarding Gloves Be?

Snowboarding gloves should be thought of in the same way as skiing gloves; apart from you won’t have to grip onto any poles, so you also have the choice of mittens. When I go snowboarding on extremely cold days, I will wear a medium-thickness glove inside of my Hestra Army Leather Heli Ski Gloves which always keep my hands warm and dry.

How Tight Should Motorcycle Gloves Be?

Motorcycle gloves should fit snugly and have good flexibility despite heavy-duty protection (which is most important). Motorbike gloves need to be warm, durable (often lined with kevlar), and well-fitted so that you can still operate turn signals and the throttle. Oversized gloves can be incredibly dangerous on a motorcycle because one wrong move could cost you your life, so it is crucial to get a good fit.

loose fitting glove vs tight glove

Is It Better for Gloves to Be Tight or Loose?

Tight gloves often improve your finger dexterity as there is no loose material. The downside of tight gloves is that they get increasingly more uncomfortable the longer you wear them.

Gloves that are too big don’t keep your hands as warm and are annoying to handle anything with. The upside of baggy gloves is that you can always add liners to fill them out, and they are rarely uncomfortable, the same way that tight gloves are.

If I had to choose between gloves that were slightly too tight or slightly too large, I will normally take the tighter gloves. But at a certain point, gloves that are too small become too tight to wear, in which case the larger gloves would be better.

Should You Size up Or Down for Gloves

There is no need to order gloves a size up or a size down unless you have a good reason to do so. For example, if you have really short fingers, then a smaller size makes sense, or if you plan to wear your gloves over the top of another pair, then getting a size up is the right thing to do.

If you are ordering online, then measuring your hands and matching them to your glove’s dimensions is a sensible approach. Remember, though, that all brands are not the same, and just because one type of glove fits doesn’t mean another will.

motorcycle gloves with extra protection

How Tight Should Leather Gloves Be?

Leather gloves have a little bit more give than synthetic gloves and will adapt to the size of your hand over time. Leather gloves should fit your hands the same way a leather jacket should fit your torso, or a leather boot should fit your foot. Snug but not too tight.

You can apply oils to soften the leather and make it easier to stretch. Also, leather tends to form to the shape of your hand over time. This means that leather gloves should feel a little tighter when brand new.

How To Measure Your Hands for Gloves

There are only two measurements you need from your hands to find your glove size with most brands. Palm width measures across your hand, and finger length measures from your knuckle to the ends of your fingers. Most gloves don’t have sizing this sophisticated and instead have a one size fits all approach or a small, medium, and large option.

Here is a glove sizing guide to give you a rough idea of how you might go about measuring your hands so that your gloves aren’t too tight or too big:

top 10 best bushcraft gloves sizing chart

Thanks for reading this guide on how tight should gloves be. Please share your comments below.

Gear Assistant
Gear Assistant

This article has been written and/or edited by Andrew N. 20+ years of hiking, mountaineering, and camping experience, with access to all the latest outdoor gear.

  1. […] your snowboard boots, the sides of your feet should be compressed slightly. To ensure you get a tight fit all the way around the sides of your feet, make sure the boot laces are tight from the very bottom […]

Gear Assistant